It is likely one of the most replayed moments within the historical past of presidential debates.
Standing on a stage in Kansas Metropolis in October 1984, President Ronald Reagan was requested the query that was on most everybody’s thoughts. He was the oldest president ever, and had been described as being “very drained” after an earlier debate. Did he have any questions in his thoughts about his potential to perform if disadvantaged of sleep throughout a nationwide safety disaster?
Reagan, 73 on the time, mentioned, “By no means.” And, after scowling for a second, he submitted to a flicker of a smile as he added, “I can’t make age a difficulty of this marketing campaign. I’m not going to use — for political functions – my opponent’s youth and inexperience.”
The query of how previous is simply too previous has additionally dogged President Biden, the oldest president ever to take the oath of workplace. Polls have discovered even Democratic voters categorical doubts about whether or not he is too previous for the job. He informed CBS 60 Minutes that his reply to the age query is, “Watch me,” citing his schedule and vitality stage.
On Sunday, Biden turns 80. He has mentioned he will probably be speaking along with his household throughout the subsequent couple of months about whether or not to make good on an intention to hunt a second time period, on the finish of which he can be 86.
“I am a terrific respecter of destiny. And that is, finally, a household determination,” Biden informed reporters earlier this month. “I believe all people desires me to run, however … we’ll have discussions about it.”
In 1984, when Reagan deflected the age query on the controversy stage with humor, everybody within the room laughed. That included Reagan’s opponent, veteran senator and former vice chairman Walter Mondale, age 56 — at the same time as he knew his slim probability of beating Reagan had simply vanished. The incumbent went on to hold 49 states, a landslide victory.
However there may be way more to the story than what’s often remembered. The query of Reagan’s health had been very a lot within the air previous to that assembly in Kansas Metropolis. In an earlier debate, Reagan had appeared fuzzy on details. When talking of army uniforms, he struggled and got here up with the phrase “wardrobe,” a time period extra acceptable to his years as a film star.
Hypothesis over Reagan’s acuity loomed over the political dialog. Time journal drew the candidates on cartoon horses operating down a observe with the headline: “A Actual Race?”
Reagan’s avuncular model lent itself to concealing uncertainty in a cloak of affability. However even on that stage in Kansas Metropolis, minutes after his marvelous quip appeared to bury the age challenge, Reagan’s closing speech raised questions.
Requested to sum up, he began describing a visit he and his spouse Nancy had taken down California’s coastal Freeway 1 years earlier. The story meandered, very like that freeway. These current within the auditorium, together with this author, felt a rising sense of discomfort as Reagan continued on, aimlessly.
The moderator, NBC’s Edwin Newman, lastly interrupted and lower him off. And the room shifted again to its earlier temper of assurance. Reagan was okay. Wasn’t he?
Lapses in consideration or effectiveness in his second time period had been generally attributed to his age. Voters, nonetheless, didn’t appear troubled. When Reagan’s time period was up, 40 states voted for his vice chairman, George H.W. Bush, to succeed him. Bush was 13 years youthful than Reagan however very a lot a part of the World Conflict II technology.
Years after Reagan left workplace, the nation would be taught he had Alzheimer’s illness, a degenerative situation that finally claimed his life. The revelation of the analysis reignited questions on whether or not there had been indicators of early signs throughout his second time period.
Biden is the primary octogenarian within the Oval Workplace. Solely three others earlier than him had been of their 70s whereas within the White Home. The primary was Dwight Eisenhower, who turned 70 simply earlier than his time period resulted in January 1961, and the second was Reagan, who was 77 when he left.
Till Biden, Donald Trump had been the oldest president on his inauguration day. Trump was 74 when he left workplace, and has filed paperwork to run once more. If he returned to workplace, he can be 82 by the top of that time period.
Whereas airline pilots face necessary retirement at 65, federal legislation enforcement at 65, and judges in some states at 70, there isn’t any age restrict for elected federal workplace holders. The rule is that the voters determine.
As a reference level, examine the U.S. Senate, the place Iowa Republican Charles Grassley was simply elected to a different six-year time period. He is already 89. Again in 2003, South Carolina Republican Strom Thurmond retired at 100.
However senators, regardless of how essential, are usually not presidents. They’ll take a time off, or perhaps a week or a month. They don’t seem to be the day by day custodians of the nuclear codes, with all that suggests.
The Structure requires members of Congress to be 25 and presidents and vice presidents to be 35. That is it. No higher age restrict. And apparently the contributors on the conference that wrote that doc in 1787 had been under no circumstances involved with an higher restrict. Which will have been as a result of they themselves had been comparatively younger, averaging 42 years. The youngest was simply 26, the oldest, Benjamin Franklin, was 81. (He was carried to and from the periods in a sedan chair.)
Age was an implicit distinction within the 1992 election, when Invoice Clinton challenged incumbent President George H.W. Bush. Clinton was a youthful 46 when he was first nominated, and was nonetheless broadly perceived because the “Boy Governor” first elected in Arkansas when he was simply 32.
Bush was 22 years his senior. On the time, it was the widest age hole between the 2 main events’ nominees since earlier than the Civil Conflict.
In 1996, when President Invoice Clinton was looking for re-election at age 50, the age challenge was raised in one other presidential debate in 1996. His Republican challenger was Bob Dole, a longtime senator who was then 73.
“I do not suppose Senator Dole is simply too previous to be president. It is the age of his concepts that I query,” Clinton mentioned.
Dole didn’t appear overly ruffled by references to his age, though he did generate nervousness halfway via the marketing campaign when he leaned on a flimsy railing and fell a brief distance from the stage at a marketing campaign rally.
Candidates must be conscious of each public transfer they make. That picture of Dole’s tumble has since served as a reminder that this crucial applies particularly to these of a sure age.
Copyright 2022 NPR. To see extra, go to https://www.npr.org.